The Masquelet Technique for the Treatment of Massive Bone Defects – Part I

image 5

The Masquelet Technique for the Treatment of Massive Bone Defects – Part I

Part I: Historical Development of the Technique and the Biological Principles of Bone Reconstruction

By Dr. Imad Al Hariri
Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon

Based on a lecture on the importance of the Masquelet technique in the reconstruction of massive bone defects, delivered at the Annual Orthopaedic Surgery Conference, 2018, Omayyad Hotel, Damascus.

Article type: Narrative Review

Topics: Massive Bone Defect Reconstruction – Surgical Technique


Introduction

Massive bone defects (critical bone defects) are among the most complex problems in orthopaedic surgery. They represent a major challenge for surgeons because of the difficulty of reconstructing bone while preserving the normal function of the affected limb. This challenge becomes even greater when the injury is associated with severe soft-tissue damage, bone infection, or follows the surgical resection of bone tumours.

Interest in this problem has increased over recent decades as a result of the rising number of high-energy injuries caused by road traffic accidents, war-related and blast injuries, as well as the increasing number of extensive bone tumour resections. These developments have led to the introduction of new bone reconstruction techniques, one of the most important being the Induced Membrane Technique, internationally known as the Masquelet Technique.

This technique has brought a major change in the management of large bone defects because it has made it possible to reconstruct extensive segments of bone using autologous bone grafts, without the need for microsurgery or the complex procedures that were previously considered the only options for such cases.


What Is a Bone Defect?

A bone defect refers to the loss of a segment of bone to such an extent that spontaneous healing is no longer possible, regardless of how long the patient is allowed to wait.

This may occur in several clinical situations, particularly:

    • Severe open fractures.
    • War injuries and gunshot wounds.
    • Blast injuries.
    • Chronic osteomyelitis following surgical debridement.
    • Bone tumour resection.
    • Failure of previous operations associated with the development of nonunion or a pseudoarthrosis.

تقنية ماسكليه (Masquelet Technique) في معالجة الضياعات العظمية الواسعة-صورة ضياع عظمي واسع في الساق

Figure 1: Radiograph showing a massive bone defect in a long bone before treatment.


Why Are Massive Bone Defects Difficult to Treat?

Bone has a remarkable capacity for regeneration. However, this capacity becomes limited when the size of the defect exceeds a certain threshold, at which point the body loses its ability to form a new bone bridge between the two ends of the defect.

Bone healing is influenced by several important factors, including:

    • The length of the bone defect.
    • The integrity of the blood supply.
    • The availability of adequate soft-tissue coverage.
    • The absence of infection.
    • The stability of bone fixation.

Clinical experience has shown that autologous cancellous bone grafts alone become insufficient when the defect exceeds approximately 4–5 cm. In such circumstances, the graft may undergo progressive resorption before it has had the opportunity to form new bone, even when the local blood supply is adequate, as discussed in your lecture.


How Were These Cases Treated in the Past?

Before the introduction of the Masquelet technique, treatment options were limited. The main approaches included the following:

1. Vascularized Bone Graft

This technique involves transferring a segment of bone together with its blood supply using microsurgical techniques.

Advantages

    • Preserves bone viability.
    • Suitable for selected large bone defects.

Disadvantages

    • Requires a specialised microsurgical team.
    • Prolonged operative time.
    • Risk of vascular failure.
    • Complications at the donor site.

2. Ilizarov Bone Transport

This method involves performing an osteotomy and gradually transporting a bone segment using an external fixator until the defect is filled.

Although this technique has produced excellent results in many cases, it requires:

    • Several months of treatment.
    • A high level of patient cooperation.
    • Tolerance of an external fixator for prolonged periods.
    • Acceptance of possible complications, such as pin-site infections and joint deformities.

3. Conventional Autologous Bone Grafts

This is the simplest approach; however, its usefulness is limited in large defects because the required graft volume becomes substantial. In addition, the graft may undergo resorption before it is converted into living bone.

4. Allogeneic Bone Grafts

These grafts are obtained from other individuals and may be fresh or frozen. They are associated with potential complications, including rejection and infection. Their use also requires the availability of a properly equipped bone bank for preservation and processing.


The Beginning of a Revolution: The Discovery of the Masquelet Technique

In 1986, the French surgeon Professor Alain-Charles Masquelet observed an interesting biological phenomenon while treating bone defects using polymethylmethacrylate bone cement (PMMA).

He found that the body formed a biological membrane around the cement. This membrane was rich in blood vessels and biologically active cells. It was not merely an inflammatory reaction, as had previously been believed, but possessed biological characteristics closely resembling those of the natural periosteum.

This discovery led to the development of a new surgical technique based on using this membrane as a biological chamber that receives the bone graft, protects it, and supports bone regeneration.

طريقة ماسكليه لمعالجة الضياعات العظمية الواسعة- البروفيسور Alain-Charles Masquelet

Figure 2: Professor Alain-Charles Masquelet.

The Basic Concept of the Masquelet Technique

The technique is based on a simple but highly effective principle.

Instead of placing the bone graft directly into the defect, the space is first filled with bone cement (PMMA). The body responds to this cement as a foreign material and, over several weeks, forms a biological membrane that completely surrounds it.

Once this membrane has developed, the cement is removed while preserving the membrane intact. The cavity is then filled with autologous cancellous bone graft within this biological chamber.

The membrane provides a suitable environment for protecting the graft, promoting revascularisation, and releasing growth factors that stimulate the formation of new bone.

As explained in your lecture, this membrane makes it possible to reconstruct large bone defects without the need for microsurgery. The technique may also be used in cases involving infection after the infectious focus has been controlled, and it can be combined with different methods of bone fixation.

تقنية ماسكلية-الضياعات العظمية الواسعة صورة (3) : رسم تخطيطي للمراحل

Figure 3: Schematic illustration of the six stages:

    1. Bone defect.
    2. Stabilisation of the bone using a strong fixation construct.
    3. Filling the defect with bone cement.
    4. Formation of the induced membrane.
    5. Removal of the cement and insertion of the bone graft.
    6. Bone union.

Why Did This Technique Represent a Major Breakthrough?

The Masquelet technique has several advantages that have contributed to its worldwide adoption, including:

    • The ability to reconstruct large bone defects.
    • More effective utilisation of autologous bone grafts.
    • No need for microsurgery in most cases.
    • Potential use in the presence of infection after adequate debridement and control of the infection.
    • Compatibility with different methods of bone fixation.
    • Relative simplicity of application compared with some alternative techniques.
    • Good results even in complex cases and war-related injuries.

For these reasons, the technique has become one of the fundamental approaches in specialised bone reconstruction centres around the world.


Summary of Part I

The discovery of the induced membrane represented a turning point in the concept of treating massive bone defects. Rather than considering bone cement merely as a temporary material used to fill a defect, it became a means of stimulating the formation of an active biological environment that helps protect the bone graft and promotes bone reconstruction.

This concept has opened new possibilities for treating massive bone defects resulting from trauma, infection, tumours, and war injuries. Encouraging clinical results have established the Masquelet technique as one of the most important modern approaches in reconstructive bone surgery.

References

    1. Masquelet AC. The concept of induced membrane for reconstruction of long bone defects. Orthop Clin North Am. 2010. J Orthop Surg Res. 2024 Sep 28;19:600. doi: 10.1186/s13018-024-05093-0.
    2. Giannoudis PV, et al. Masquelet technique for the treatment of bone defects: tips, tricks and future directions. Injury. 2011. PMID: 21543068. DOI: 10.1016/j.injury.2011.03.036.
    3. Taylor BC, et al. Induced membrane technique for reconstruction to manage bone loss. JAAOS. 2012. PMID: 22382286. DOI: 10.5435/JAAOS-20-03-142.
    4. Karger C, et al. Treatment of post-traumatic bone defects by the induced membrane technique. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2012. PMID: 22244249. DOI: 10.1016/j.otsr.2011.11.001.
    5. Morelli I, et al. Systematic review and meta-analysis. Injury. 2016. PMID: 28040090. DOI: 10.1016/S0020-1383(16)30842-7.

Further Reading: The Masquelet Technique Series

    • Part II: The Induced Membrane – Histological Structure and Biological Properties.
    • Part III: Indications for the Masquelet Technique and Selection of Suitable Patients.
    • Part IV: The Masquelet Technique for the Treatment of Massive Bone Defects.
    • Part V: The Masquelet Technique for the Treatment of Massive Bone Defects.
    • Part VI: Can Massive Bone Defects Be Reconstructed Using a Hybrid Approach?

Dr. Imad Al Hariri
Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon